Emily Setty

Dr Emily Setty


Associate Professor in Criminology

Academic and research departments

Faculty of Arts, Business and Social Sciences, Sociology.

About

Areas of specialism

Youth; Sexual culture; Qualitative research; Sexual consent ; Digital culture; Relationships and Sex Education

University roles and responsibilities

  • Programme Director for Criminology
  • MSc Dissertation Lead

    Affiliations and memberships

    Academic networks

      News

      In the media

      Youth sexting: Replacing abstinence with ethics
      Young men and sexting: It's not always easy being a teenage boy in youth digital sexual culture 
      鈥極ur smartphone policy does not make us anti-technology鈥
      Author
      糖心Vlog Sociology Blog
      The Daily Mail
      Author
      The Conversation
      Author
      The Conversation
      Contributor
      Times Education Supplement
      Contributor
      Women's Hour - Radio 4
      Author
      The Conversation
      2024
      Author
      The Conversation
      Author
      The Conversation
      Author
      The Conversation
      Author
      糖心Vlog Sociology Blog

      Research

      Research interests

      Supervision

      Postgraduate research supervision

      Postgraduate research supervision

      Teaching

      Publications

      Setty, E (2019)

      Educational interventions on youth sexting often focus on individual sexters or would-be sexters, and are driven by the aim of encouraging young people to abstain from producing and sharing personal sexual images. This approach has been criticised for failing to engage with the complex sociocultural context to youth sexting. Drawing upon qualitative group and one-to-one interviews with 41 young people aged 14 to 18 living in a county in south-east England, I explore young people鈥檚 perceptions and practices surrounding sexting. By taking a grounded theory approach to the research, I reveal how young people鈥檚 shaming of digitally mediated sexual self-expression shaped and was shaped by a denial of rights to bodily and sexual autonomy and integrity. This denial of rights underpinned harmful sexting practices, including violations of privacy and consent, victim blaming, and bullying. I conclude that responses to youth sexting should attend to this broader youth cultural context, emphasise the roles and responsibilities of bystanders, and encourage a collectivist digital sexual ethics based upon rights to one鈥檚 body and freedom from harm (Albury, New Media and Society 19(5):713鈥725, 2017; Dobson and Ringrose, Sex Education&苍产蝉辫;16(1):8鈥21,&苍产蝉辫;2015).

      Setty E (2019)

      Young men tend to be constructed as being at low risk of harm and able to extract value from sexting, compared to young women. Drawing upon findings from a qualitative study exploring practices and perceptions of sexting among 14鈥18 year-old participants in southeast England, I discuss the meanings and norms surrounding young men鈥檚 sexting practices. I outline how these meanings and norms underpinned perceptions regarding the value available to young men through sexting. Young men were not, however, equally able to extract value and social capital through sexting, and participants discussed examples of the social shaming of young men who sext. I discuss how young men took up diverse positions with regard to masculine heterosexuality within youth sexting culture, in which they reworked and challenged the ideals and assumptions inherent to 鈥榟egemonic masculinity鈥. I draw two conclusions: firstly, it should not be assumed that young men are inherently able to gain value through sexting; secondly, narratives of risk and shame may mean that while young men distance themselves from sexting, gendered assumptions and inequalities regarding bodily and sexual expression remain.

      Setty E (2018)

      Youth sexters are considered vulnerable to privacy violations in the form of unauthorized distribution, in which sexts are distributed beyond the intended recipient without the consent of the subject. This article draws on group and one-to-one interviews with young people 14 to 18 years of age living in southeastern England to show how they constructed privacy rights and obligations in sexting. The analysis suggests that their constructions were shaped by individualistic orientations to risk management, social meanings of privacy in the 鈥渄igital world,鈥 and broader norms and values regarding gender, trust, and approved conduct of behavior in intimate relationships. The article concludes that educational and community interventions on sexting with young people should deconstruct and challenge narrow ethical frameworks regarding privacy rights and obligations, and young people鈥檚 tendency to blame and responsibilize victims of privacy violations in sexting.

      Setty E (2018)

      The present paper explores how young people construct gendered social meanings and cultural norms surrounding sexual and bodily expression in youth sexting culture. Previous research suggests youth sexting is a gendered phenomenon in which young men are able to seek social capital through sexting, whereas young women are subject to social shaming and harassment. Drawing upon findings from group and one-to-one interviews with 41 young people aged 14鈥18, I show how constructs of risk, shame, and responsibility operated along gendered lines. Young people attributed agency and legitimacy to young men鈥檚 sexual practices, whereas young women were disempowered, denied legitimacy, and tasked with managing gendered risks of harm in youth sexting culture. I discuss how young women negotiated and navigated risk and shame and, in some instances, made space for safe, pleasurable sexting experiences despite and within these narratives. The accounts of two young women, who shared experiences sexting and social shaming, are presented to show some of the ways young women make sense of social meanings and cultural norms on individual and interpersonal levels. I conclude that challenging gendered harm requires a (re)legitimisation of feminine sexuality and bodily expression away from narratives of risk and shame.

      Setty E (2018)

      This thesis explores young people鈥檚 perceptions and practices surrounding 鈥榶outh sexting鈥, particularly regarding privacy and consent. Youth sexting 鈥 involving the production and exchange of sexual images or messages via mobile phones and other communication technologies 鈥 has attracted media attention, public concern, and research and policy focus for some time, particularly regarding the perceived harmful nature of the practice (Crofts et al., 2015). This thesis situates harmful practices in terms of breaches of privacy and consent. The research is used to advocate for progressive, harm-reduction approaches to responding to youth sexting that centralise ethics, justice and equality, and give rights to sexual and bodily expression and exploration, as well as freedom from harm. Group and one-to-one interviews with young people revealed narratives of individualism and responsibilisation regarding harmful sexting practices. Intertwined were moralising discourses about harm-avoidance, which underpinned a demarcation of deserving and undeserving victims, and promoted victim-blaming. Analyses revealed however, that risk and harm was not inherent to sexting and was shaped by norms and standards surrounding gender and sexuality, and local peer group dynamics and hierarchies. The designation of some forms of bodily and sexual expression as shameful and illegitimate shaped harmful practices and were incorporated into young people鈥檚 self-concepts in ways that both reproduced and resisted established systems of meaning. The findings suggest that rather than being caused by technology, youth sexting should be understood as a complex, negotiated practice situated within young people鈥檚 peer, digital, relational, and sexual cultures. The thesis explores young people鈥檚 perspectives on addressing youth sexting, and concludes by emphasising the need to disrupt and challenge the meanings underpinning shame and stigma, and the responsibilisation of individuals to deal with inequality and harm.

      Setty E and Ringrose J () Youth sexting Encyclopaedic Entry
      Setty E (2017)
      Setty E (2016)
      Setty E (2020)

      This book draws upon interviews with teenage young people to explore their perspectives on risk and harm in 鈥榶outh sexting culture鈥. It focuses specifically on digital sexual image-sharing among young people. It contextualises the findings in terms of the wider literature on youth sexting and the broader theoretical and conceptual debates about the phenomenon in public and academic spheres.

      The book explores young people鈥檚 attitudes toward and experiences of non-consensual sexting and privacy violations. It analyses the broader sociocultural context to youth sexting and discusses issues such as victim-blaming, social shaming and bullying within youth sexting culture. It reflects upon the nature of predominant approaches to responding to youth sexting (both legal and educational/pedagogic) and identifies what young people want and need when it comes to addressing risk and harm, based upon what the evidence shows about their situated realities and lived experiences.

      Public and academic discourse surrounding youth sexting, and the legal and educational policy responses to the phenomenon have developed and changed over recent years. The field is increasingly contested and there are ongoing debates about how to protect young people from harm while respecting their rights as individuals and encouraging them to develop into ethical sexual citizens, including within digital environments. This book presents empirical data to show how risk and harm in youth sexting culture is predicated upon a denial of rights to sexual and bodily integrity, autonomy and legitimacy.

      Setty, E. (2020)

      Sexual consent has increasingly become a central component of Relationships and Sex Education. This paper draws upon findings from qualitative research conducted with teenagers in England, which explored their perspectives on consent within their contemporary youth sexual cultures, including in digital (sexting) contexts. The findings suggest that young people鈥檚 definitions of consent often did not correspond to the socially- and contextually contingent realities of negotiating and establishing consensual sex(ting). While young people鈥檚 contemporary sexual cultures may look somewhat different, longstanding gender norms and sexual scripts shaped their attitudes towards consent. The implications of the findings for RSE are discussed, including the need for more collaborative dialogue and exchange between educators and learners that engages with the situated realities of contemporary youth sexual culture.

      Setty E (2021)

      This paper draws upon research conducted in a co-educational independent boarding school in England to explore the role of pornography in students鈥 school-based sexual cultures. Drawing upon Mechling鈥檚 conceptualization of boarding schools as 鈥榯otal institutions鈥, I explore how pornography acted as both 鈥榩lay鈥 and 鈥榬itual鈥 through which participants asserted agency and control while producing a gendered social order surrounding sex and sexuality. Participants who spoke about pornography drew upon dominant understandings of masculine and feminine (hetero)sexuality when positioning themselves and one another regarding pornography. They tended to construct viewing pornography as a 鈥榯ypical鈥 and 鈥榥ormal鈥 part of masculine (hetero)sexuality but as antithetical to feminine (hetero)sexuality. Some of the boys expressed ambivalence and uncertainty about pornography, but this was often grounded in taken-for-granted gendered constructs about sexual performance and accomplishment. Socially approved expressions of agency and control within the research environment were, therefore, both reflective and constitutive of a gendered and heteronormative social order. I suggest that sex education should attend to the role that pornography plays as a cultural resource through which young people construct, express and designate gendered sexual subjectivities and social roles.

      Setty E (2021)
      Setty E (2021)

      This paper presents an examination of 鈥榝rexting鈥 (鈥榝riend鈥欌+鈥夆榮exting鈥), which is defined as the exchange of personally-produced intimate images among friends. It draws upon accounts of frexting shared by teenage girls during a 2016 study investigating sexting conducted in 糖心Vlog, England. Frexting is theorised as a form of homosociality among girls and explores the extent to which and how it reflects, reproduces and subverts the dominant gendered social order within youth digital intimacies. The analysis suggests that while frexting involves intimate self-representation away from the male gaze, it reflects and reinforces a post-feminist cultural landscape characterised by (self-)scrutiny and regulation of girls鈥 bodies and bodily self-representations. Frexting worked to demonstrate an authentic, relaxed, carefree and confident but, importantly, non-sexual sensibility, with implications for who and what constitutes legible participation. While subverting normative interpretations of girls鈥 bodies as inherently, and problematically, sexual, frexting did not fundamentally trouble the post-feminist cultural landscape within which the girls were operating. The paper concludes by arguing that for frexting to become a truly emancipatory endeavour, it is necessary to dismantle the socio-cultural context that restricts and regulates girls鈥 abilities to relate to and represent their bodies.

      Setty E (2021)

      Young people鈥檚 use of digital and internet technologies, particularly the risks and harms they face online, continues to be of public and policy concern. Adult stakeholders 鈥 parents, teachers, law enforcement, youth practitioners, policy makers and researchers 鈥 are, in various ways, mindful of how young people can be protected from so-called online harms while not unduly curtailing their opportunities to reap the benefits of being online. The UK government鈥檚 Online Safety Bill seeks to do just that (Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, 2021) and since September 2021 it has been mandatory for most schools in England to educate young people about digital safety as part of the newly introduced Relationships, Sex and Health Education (RSHE) curriculum (Department for Education, 2019). This article does not directly engage in a critique of the specifics of this policy and practice agenda (see Nash, 2019, for a dissection of the issues with the online harms policy proposals). Instead, I discuss findings from some recent research conducted with young people about their perspectives on online harms in order to explore how we should seek to understand and respond to the realities of young people鈥檚 digital lives, in all their complexity and heterogeneity.

      On the basis of the findings, I argue that individualistic, technical and decontextualised solutions to online harms will not suffice in light of, first, the high levels of normalisation (and fatalism) surrounding potentially harmful online experiences; and, second, the social and structural contingencies that shape young people鈥檚 digital lives and thus give rise to an unequal terrain of risk. It is urgent that educational interventions raise young people鈥檚 critical consciousness about the nature of risk and harm online, not necessarily to solve the issues but to enable them to connect what they see and experience online to wider inequities and injustices. In so doing, interventions can support their resilience in a way that is sensitive to the differential risks that young people face and can encourage reporting and positive models of bystander intervention online.

      Lloyd J and Setty E (2020)

      The previous indicator looked at adolescents鈥 experiences of online harm. It includes data from the Internet Watch Foundation (IWF), which shows that increasing numbers of online sexual abuse images involving adolescents are being identified. This rise is partly driven by an increase in 鈥榮elf-produced鈥 content, where young people had taken and shared images themselves. Here Dr Jenny Lloyd and Dr Emily Setty look at why adolescents sext, when this behaviour becomes harmful and what can be done to tackle it.

      Setty, E., Ringrose, J. and Regehr, K. (2022)
      Setty, E (2022)

      Young people encounter and experience both risks and opportunities when participating as actors and interactors in online spaces. Digital skills and resilience are considered important parts of a 鈥渞ights-based鈥 approach to keeping young people 鈥渟afe鈥 online in ways that enable them to avoid harm while benefiting from the opportunities. The present paper discusses findings from focus group research conducted in England with 60 young people aged 13 to 21. The research explored their perspectives on responding to different online harms, including online hate, unwanted sexual content, and unrealistic body- and appearance-related content. The findings are discussed in terms of scholarship on digital citizenship, specifically regarding the social, affective, and technical dimensions of online life and the skills required for resilience. The analysis suggests that there was a tension between young people鈥檚 individualistic responsibilisation of themselves and one another for responding to risk online and the socio-emotional aspects of online life as perceived and recounted by them in the focus groups. It is concluded that a youth-centred approach to resilience is required that encapsulates the multidimensional nature of encountering, experiencing, and responding to risk online.

      Setty E (2022)

      Young people鈥檚 socio-sexual lives and development have become increasingly digitally mediated over recent years. There are implications for classroom-based Relationships, Sex, and Health Education (RSHE), which has recently been made mandatory in most state-maintained schools in England. The evidence base pertaining to good practice in RSHE is extensive and identifies a need for RSHE to be relatable and relevant to learners, and to position learners as active participants in the pedagogic process. Typically, young people鈥檚 use of digital media is considered a risk or problem to address in RSHE and this includes their use of digital media for formal and informal learning about sex and relationships. This paper explores the potential value of digital media to classroom based RSHE. It considers how using digital media in the classroom could help to convey material in a relatable and relevant way, including how the 鈥榠nfluencer model鈥 may represent a new opportunity for or form of peer delivered education. It also discusses the value of strengthening young people鈥檚 skills in identifying reliable and trustworthy content and in applying the content to their own lives, which may necessitate opportunities for independent and self-directed learning away from the classroom.

      Setty E and Dobson E (2022)

      This paper examines the participation of children and young people within government consultation processes. It considers the recent Department for Education consultation on its statutory guidance for schools for Relationships and Sex Education in England. The paper is based on a Freedom of Information request for the consultation responses categorised as from 鈥榶oung people鈥. We identify two issues in our interrogation of the data. First, there is evidence that a substantial proportion of responses were not submitted by young people. Second, the consultation approach did not include all the features necessary for meaningful consultation. We consider the implications for the youth consultation on policy matters that affect them.

      Setty E and Dobson E (2022)

      In England, the Children and Social Work Act (HMSO, 2017) bestowed compulsory status on relationships and sex education (RSE), which means that young people鈥檚 right to receive RSE has been codifed in law. This paper analyzes how this right is upheld and enacted within the Department for Education (DfE) (2019) statutory guidance on RSE for schools in England. The analysis suggests that the guidance features contradictory discourses in which young people鈥檚 rights are ostensibly advanced, but remain structured by adult-centric, heteronormative understandings of sex and relationships. It upholds a decontextualized and legalistic approach to rights, responsibilities, informed choice, and decision making. A narrow conception of rights is particularly evident regarding young people鈥檚 digital sexual cultures, which are predominantly framed in terms of risk and harm. We argue that scholars should investigate how educators are designing and delivering RSE in light of the guidance, and the opportunities for and obstacles to a genuinely 鈥渞ights-based鈥 approach to RSE. While the policy discussed in this article is specific to England, the discussion has wider relevance for practitioners and policymakers across cultural and geographic contexts as it draws upon a model for analyzing how young people鈥檚 sexuality is presented and addressed in legislative and curricular documentation.

      Setty, E, Ringrose, J and Regehr, K (2022)

      This chapter discusses two qualitative studies exploring youth intimate image sharing, conducted with 191 British young people over a four-year period. We explore a discursive absence of consent in the data and discuss how image sharing occurs within inequitable gendered cultures of normalised online sexual harassment and abuse. We describe the technological affordances that create temporal and material endurance of images and explore how these affordances compromise consent in digital contexts in gender-specific ways. We discuss the pressure on girls to send nudes and how boys鈥 desire for girls鈥 nudes also drives transactional, uninvited 鈥渄ick pics.鈥 We then consider the non-consensual sharing of images of girls and boys and demonstrate how the implications are often worse and longer lasting for girls. We show how the increased risk of non-consensual sharing of girls鈥 nudes led to heightened responsibilization of girls for the life of their images, as well as long-lasting feelings of regret and shame for creating and sending nude images of their bodies. We argue for a change in educational messages around sexual consent to explicitly address cultures of normalised abuse that surround the life of images in digital contexts.

      Setty E (2022)

      Educating boys about consent in schools in England is required as part of the now-statutory Relationships, Sex, and Health Education curriculum and, moreover, is considered important for addressing sexual violence, abuse, and harassment among young people. The present paper draws on qualitative data collected in three schools in southeast England to explore how boys are being taught about consent and how they relate to and interpret educational messages about consent in terms of their sociosexual subjectivities and peer sexual cultures. Data was collected during May鈥揓une 2022 through classroom observations, focus groups with boys, and discussions with teachers in a co-educational academy, a boys鈥 academy, and a boys鈥 independent school, all in southeast England. The data suggests that while typical consent education messages may rationalise or provide a 鈥榬oad map鈥 for consent, the boys felt uncertain and anxious about navigating the perceived, often anticipated, realities of youth sexual culture. The framing of sexual activity as only consensual, and thus legitimate, if there is a clear and direct yes, conficted with these realities. As supposed initiators of sex, as masculine heterosexual subjects, the boys felt a responsibility for obtaining consent yet seemed to lack confdence regarding the socio-afective skills required for doing so. The paper calls for an integrated model of consent education that addresses knowledge, skills (including emotional literacy), and the normative contextual contingencies that constrain the operation of free choice.

      Setty E (2022)

      Educating boys about consent in schools in England is required as part of the now-statutory Relationships, Sex, and Health Education curriculum and, moreover, is considered important for addressing sexual violence, abuse, and harassment among young people. The present paper draws on qualitative data collected in three schools in southeast England to explore how boys are being taught about consent and how they relate to and interpret educational messages about consent in terms of their sociosexual subjectivities and peer sexual cultures. Data was collected during May鈥揓une 2022 through classroom observations, focus groups with boys, and discussions with teachers in a co-educational academy, a boys鈥 academy, and a boys鈥 independent school, all in southeast England. The data suggests that while typical consent education messages may rationalise or provide a 鈥榬oad map鈥 for consent, the boys felt uncertain and anxious about navigating the perceived, often anticipated, realities of youth sexual culture. The framing of sexual activity as only consensual, and thus legitimate, if there is a clear and direct yes, conflicted with these realities. As supposed initiators of sex, as masculine heterosexual subjects, the boys felt a responsibility for obtaining consent yet seemed to lack confidence regarding the socio-affective skills required for doing so. The paper calls for an integrated model of consent education that addresses knowledge, skills (including emotional literacy), and the normative contextual contingencies that constrain the operation of free choice.

      Setty E and Dobson E (2023)

      Romantic and intimate relationships are crucial for the socio-emotional development of young adults. However, the Covid-19 pandemic and the resulting 鈥榣ockdown鈥 restrictions imposed by the UK government limited opportunities for in-person relationships in England during 2020-21. This paper discusses young adults鈥 experiences of their relationships during lockdown, based on findings from 36 qualitative interviews conducted during 2021-22. The data suggests that relationships were shaped by socially and contextually contingent processes of meaning making and experience. Lockdown served as a defining condition, which constrained and reshaped these processes. The findings emphasise the importance of understanding relationships as entailing dynamic interactions between individual subjectivity, interpersonal experiences, and social norms. Identifying the evolving contextual conditions in which these processes occur is vital. While this study specifically examined the impact of lockdown, its implications extend beyond through shedding light on how young adults navigate social conditions and make choices for themselves and their relationships.

      Setty E (2022)

      Young people鈥檚 perspectives on the potentialities of and problems with Relationships and Sex Education (RSE) in England are well documented. This article shares insights from a co-design project conducted with young people and third-sector experts during 2020/21 which sought to identify and develop recommendations for schools regarding the design and delivery of critically informed RSE that engages with the realities and complexities of youth sociosexual life and development. The article discusses findings from workshops pertaining to how RSE can address the 鈥榚cosystem鈥 of young people鈥檚 sociosexual lives and development; judgment and shame within and beyond the classroom; safe, constructive, and inclusive teaching and learning; and inclusivity and cultural sensitivity. The challenges of designing and delivering safe, inclusive, and meaningful RSE for learners, that upholds and supports their development as sexual citizens, are acknowledged and addressed.

      Setty E (2023)

      Young people鈥檚 digitally-mediated interactions entail negotiating co-existing risks and opportunities. This paper discusses youth perspectives on these risks and opportunities, based on data from focus groups conducted with 12鈥21-year-olds in England. Analysis of examples of digitally-mediated interactions shared by participants suggests that pursuing opportunities involved or created risk for oneself and/or others, while motivations to pursue opportunities were shaped by risks resulting from the actions of others. Flows of risk and opportunity were, therefore, reciprocal across a dynamic continuum of 鈥榙igital鈥 鈥 鈥榥on-digital鈥 contexts and relational both for and between young people. It is argued that a reciprocal and relational conceptualisation of 鈥榩ost-digital鈥 negotiations of risk and opportunity among youth facilitates critical engagement with their accounts of their online lives as well as identification of the interconnections between individual, interpersonal and community-ethical spheres of meaning and experience.

      Setty E (2023)

      Educating young people about sexual consent aims to help them develop healthy relationships and prevent sexual harm. Yet, there remains no consensus on how to define consent nor the connection between consent and sexual harm. This article discusses findings from qualitative research conducted with young people in England that has explored issues of sexual consent. It engages with tensions around the so-called 鈥榞rey areas鈥 and oft-critiqued 鈥榤iscommunication model鈥 of consent and suggests that some form of 鈥榤iscommunication鈥 may underpin some, albeit not all, experiences of sexual harm among young people. Young people may experience problems articulating and interpreting consent not because of malintent or substandard or disparate communication skills but because of interpersonal and sociocultural power dynamics that constrain the communication and operation of consent. Consent education needs, therefore, to support young people develop the socio-emotional skills and literacy required to navigate gendered and heterosexual (inter)personal pressures, expectations, and sexual scripts. It should involve active participation of young people whereby they identify the conditions in which sexual activity unfolds and the power dynamics that constrain the operation of consent.


       

      Setty E., Gordon F., & Nottingham E. (2024)

      Examines online harm as it pertains to children and young people within the UK context

      Draws upon children鈥檚 and young people鈥檚 views on online harms through qualitative research studies

      Critically examines these perspectives in the context of legal, policy and regulatory debates and developments

      Setty E (2022)

      This paper discusses findings from interviews conducted in England with 15 self-identified feminist mothers about sex and relationships education in the home. Participants鈥 understandings and enactments of being sexuality educators for their children involved what they described as open and honest 鈥榮ex positive鈥 communication with their children, based on their subjective views about gender and sexual rights, safety and wellbeing. Participants were concerned about protecting their children from oftentimes gendered risks of judgement shame and abuse. Feminist sex and relationships education in the home for these mothers was shaped, and sometimes constrained, by the gendered sociocultural conditions of their children鈥檚 lives. Implications are discussed regarding the need for self-reflexivity amongst feminist mothers, supported by collaborative local and community educational initiatives to identify and collectively tackle the social contexts in which risks and harms arise for children.


       

      Setty E and Dobson E (2023)

      The lockdown imposed in England in response to the COVID-19 pandemic involved an unprecedented 鈥榮hift to digital鈥, including in relationships between non-cohabiting individuals. This article examines young people鈥檚 perspectives on and experiences of using networked communication technologies (NCTs) in romantic relationships during lockdown, based on 14 focus groups (n鈥=鈥80) and interviews (n鈥=鈥38) conducted with young people in England during 2021鈥2022. Using critical realist theory, we identify interplays between lockdown as a condition, NCT affordances and wider norms, meanings and expectations for relationships. Participants were ambivalent about interacting online during lockdown, with interlocking risks and opportunities specific to and transcending lockdown as a condition. Implications are discussed regarding meanings and experiences of post-digital relationships for young people, both during and post-pandemic.


       

      Setty E, Ringrose J and Hunt J (2024)

      Sexual and gender-based violence (SGBV) in schools in England is a pressing concern, especially since the 鈥楨veryone鈥檚 Invited鈥 movement laid bare the extent of the problem across the country. This article analyses the national policy context, asserting that SGBV is a systemic problem rooted in young people鈥檚 school and online peer cultures that requires transformative solutions, involving active youth participation. We introduce and explore the utility of the concept of postdigital sexual citizenship. We contrast this approach with the prevailing behavioural science 鈥榥udge鈥 philosophy of government policy making and societal discussions on youth sexuality and rights currently shaping Relationships and Sex Education (RSE) discourse and policy in England. Challenging adult-centric, top-down methods and instead empowering young people as post-digital sexual citizens entitled to comprehensive RSE is vital. While our focus is on England, the arguments apply globally to jurisdictions tackling SGBV in schools.


       

      Setty E (2023)

      Youth produced sexual imagery (YPSI) has, for some time, been of concern to police, schools, and policymakers. There have been various iterations of policy and practice designed to address YPSI over the previous decade, with increasing nuance and awareness about the different forms of YPSI and the distinctions between 鈥榙evelopmentally normative鈥 consensual image sharing between similarly aged peers and aggravated or abusive image sharing. This chapter examines the implications of policy and practice in England surrounding YPSI for the prevention, reporting, and response to abusive image sharing among young people. It suggests that ongoing tensions in the aims and nature of the approach, in England but also comparable jurisdictions elsewhere, coupled with sociocultural, structural, and systemic victim-blaming and barriers to reporting and challenging abusive image sharing, means that it is not being sufficiently recognised or addressed in policy and practice. Suggestions are made for an improved systems response that disentangles non-consensual and abusive sharing from consensual sharing; challenges all forms of victim-blaming; and takes a holistic approach to addressing the sociocultural contextual causes of abusive image sharing and the reluctance to report and challenge abuse, including as upheld and perpetuated within the structures of the systems themselves.


       

      Setty D and Dobson E (2023)

      There were limited opportunities for in-person social, intimate, and sexual interactions in England during 2020鈥2021, due to restrictions imposed by the UK government in response to the Covid-19 pandemic. While previous studies examined the effects of lockdown on intimate relationships, there is less qualitative research regarding young people鈥檚 perspectives on and experiences of digitally mediated intimacy (sexting) during the period. This paper discusses findings from focus groups with 80 adolescents and interviews with 38 young adults that explored the topic. Analysis identified a normalization of non-consensual distribution of intimate images within adolescent peer culture and a reluctance to report or intervene in response to incidents of non-consensual distribution that are witnessed or experienced. The adolescent girls and young adult women also described other forms of unwanted and invasive image-sharing and requests for images. Young adults held various perspectives on sexting during lockdown, with some describing sexting as unfulfilling and/or 鈥渞isky鈥 and others sharing experiences of using sexting to generate intimacy and, among some, engaging in unwanted sexting with partners. By considering both adolescent and young adult perspectives obtained through focus groups and interviews, the study highlighted how group-level norms and meanings surrounding the risks and rewards of sexting may be reproduced or reworked as individuals transition from adolescence to young adulthood. The study underscores the need to support adolescents and young adults in cultivating healthy digital sexual cultures and interpersonal relationships.


       

      Setty E (2020)

      Young people today are participating in and navigating a sexualised digital media landscape. The two most prominent aspects include 鈥榩ornography鈥 鈥 which is sexually explicit material consumed by individuals 鈥 and the production and exchange of personal sexual content (for example, messages, images and recorded or live videos), which is often colloquially referred to by adults as 鈥榮exting鈥. Digital media has made sexual content ubiquitous and easy to access and produce, which contrasts with the situation for previous generations whereby a more deliberative approach to seeking out such content was required. Digital sexual content (both consumed and produced) is a normalised, almost mundane part of day-to-day life for young people online. Anyone 鈥 young or old 鈥 can access, consume and participate in sexualised digital media practices, but it is particularly important to consider young people鈥檚 perspectives and experiences because it forms part of how they learn about and experience sex and relationships as developing individuals in the contemporary digital era. In this article, I draw upon findings from studies conducted with young people to explore how we may wish to understand and respond to the realities of contemporary youth digital sexual culture, in all their complexity and heterogeneity. 

      Setty E and Pugh V (2023)
      Setty E and Ringrose J (2024)

      This chapter focuses on young people's engagement with sexually explicit content online, focusing on the legal and ethical challenges in research involving minors under 18. It considers the formal and informal adult responses to young people鈥檚 online sexual behaviors and the impacts of these responses on young people鈥檚 protection and participation rights. The chapter reflects on the authors鈥 research experiences using and avoiding the use of visual methods. Through a case study of visual methods in researching image-based sexual abuse among English adolescents, the authors argue that visual methods offer an opportunity to empower young people and to generate insights to support safeguarding. While visual methods are valuable, their use requires careful consideration of institutional and socio-political contexts to ensure ethical and effective research practices.


       

      Setty, E., Hunt, J., and Ringrose, J. (2025)

      This paper examines the policing of harmful sexual behaviour (HSB) among young people in schools, drawing on qualitative research conducted with police and schools in southeast England. Utilising a Foucauldian surveillance perspective, we explore the challenges police experience in balancing punitive measures with relationship-building efforts. We highlight contradictions between policing objectives and strategies, with police engagement often emphasising surveillance, intelligence gathering and detection, including among officers endorsing relationship-based practice with young people. The overarching concern with behaviour management and discipline of young people in schools, combined with inadequate training and resourcing, perpetuates authoritarian policing practices, with implications for police鈥搚outh relations. We identify how tensions between deterrence and trust play out through a wider crisis of legitimacy regarding the capacity for legal frameworks and criminal justice to adequately capture and respond to HSB. We suggest these limitations undermine young people's rights, erode trust between young people and police, and ultimately compromise safety through hindering the effectiveness of HSB prevention and response efforts.


       

      Mukoro, J., Setty, E., & Bullock, K. (2025)

      A systematic literature review was undertaken to investigate the cultural conflicts that arise in secondary school-based sexuality education programmes and how stakeholders respond to and navigate these conflicts. This review is reported according to PRISMA guidelines. After applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria, a final selection of 23 documents from the literature was made for analysis. Thematic analysis of the documents revealed four key themes. The first theme examines the interplay between culture and conflict in sexuality education, highlighting how cultural contexts can trigger or oppose it. The second theme focuses on the roles of stakeholders in cultural conflicts, exposing power imbalances within their influence on youth sexuality education. The third theme explores diverse stakeholder responses to cultural conflicts, ranging from silence to negotiation and conflict-informed teaching approaches. Lastly, the fourth theme investigates how conflicts shape and drive transformative changes in sexuality education, including the adoption of innovative approaches and the recognition of it as a human right. In conclusion, this article outlines the implications of these identified themes for sexuality education. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved)


       

      Setty, E., Nott, L., & Efthymiadou, E. (2026)

      This paper examines how safeguarding professionals in 30 English secondary schools respond to harmful sexual behaviour (HSB), drawing on qualitative data from a three-year action research project. Educators described navigating tensions between procedural compliance, emotional labour and the need for contextually responsive practice. Applying Lang, Little and Cronen鈥檚 (1990) domains of production, explanation and aesthetics, the paper conceptualises safeguarding as a multidimensional praxis shaped by systems, meaning-making and relational dynamics. Findings show that safeguarding often privileges compliance over trust, reflexivity and student voice. Staff reported emotional strain and inadequate structural support, while students expressed scepticism towards adult-led safeguarding perceived as disconnected from their experiences. The paper argues for relational and holistic approaches, incorporating restorative practices, student participation and strengths-based work. It calls for a move from reactive, individualised models towards a public health paradigm centred on wellbeing, contextual understanding and the co-production of safety.


       

      Mukoro, J., Setty, E., & Hemming, P. (2026)

      This article investigates the cultural conflicts experienced by teachers when delivering sex education in English secondary schools. Drawing on qualitative, semi-structured interviews with 12 secondary school teachers, conducted as part of a broader empirical study on the emotional dynamics of cultural conflict in sex education, the research examines intrapersonal, interpersonal, social, and institutional tensions within this contested educational space. Data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis supported by NVivo. Framed through symbolic interactionism and identity theory, the study positions teachers as active agents navigating power, identity, and cultural meaning-making. Findings identify four key sources of conflict: (1) student and community diversity, (2) teachers鈥 personal beliefs and experiences, (3) societal pressures and expectations, and (4) school 鈥 family dynamics. In response to these conflicts, teachers employed two main pedagogical strategies: (1) collaborative support-seeking and (2) critical self-awareness. The article highlights teachers as cultural actors mediating between policy mandates and pluralistic school environments.

       


       

      Mukoro, J., Setty, E., & Bullock, K. (2025)

      A systematic literature review was undertaken to investigate the cultural conflicts that arise in secondary school-based sexuality education programmes and how stakeholders respond to and navigate these conflicts. This review is reported according to PRISMA guidelines. After applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria, a final selection of 23 documents from the literature was made for analysis. Thematic analysis of the documents revealed four key themes. The first theme examines the interplay between culture and conflict in sexuality education, highlighting how cultural contexts can trigger or oppose it. The second theme focuses on the roles of stakeholders in cultural conflicts, exposing power imbalances within their influence on youth sexuality education. The third theme explores diverse stakeholder responses to cultural conflicts, ranging from silence to negotiation and conflict-informed teaching approaches. Lastly, the fourth theme investigates how conflicts shape and drive transformative changes in sexuality education, including the adoption of innovative approaches and the recognition of it as a human right. In conclusion, this article outlines the implications of these identified themes for sexuality education.

       


       

      Mukoro, J., Setty, E., & Hemming, P. (2025)

      England鈥檚 statutory Relationships and Sex Education (RSE) guidance mandates inclusive yet sensitive delivery of sex education in secondary schools. However, teachers 鈥 often the frontline interpreters of these policies, navigate complex emotional terrains shaped by cultural conflicts, institutional expectations, and personal beliefs. This qualitative study explores the affective dimensions of teaching sex education through semi-structured interviews with 12 secondary school teachers across England, drawing on Sara Ahmed鈥檚 theory of affective economies and Arlie Hochschild鈥檚 concept of emotional labour. Findings reveal a spectrum of emotions across three key emotional clusters: (1) positive alignment ;(joy, fulfilment) among teachers whose values aligned with institutional contexts; (2) negative distress ;(anxiety, anger, trauma) tied to cultural dissonance, personal experiences, and perceived systemic neglect; and (3) ambivalence ;(neutrality, reluctant professionalism) reflecting tensions between authenticity and institutional expectations. Teachers employed emotion regulation strategies like open communication ;(peer support, institutional dialogue) and self-care ;(counselling, grounding techniques). This study centres the lived emotional experiences of teachers 鈥 often overlooked in policy debates. By centring emotion in effective sex education, this research advocates for institutional cultures that honour teachers鈥 emotional labour while fostering inclusive, culturally responsive classrooms.

       


       

      Emily Setty, Robyn Muir, and Rosie Macpherson (2025)

      This paper examines how girls aged 9鈥15 engage with online influencer culture, focusing on interplays between digital and non-digital normative ecologies. Drawing on school-based workshops, we explore tensions between authenticity, normative ideals and self-presentation in girls鈥 interactions with influencers. Participants expressed agency in content consumption alongside pressures to conform, shaped by social interactions online and offline. We argue that influencer culture perpetuates dominant femininity norms through reciprocal dynamics between influencers and audiences. Girls navigated this terrain ambivalently, often endorsing authenticity and diversity while feeling constrained by normative expectations. We propose a post-digital literacy framework to conceptualise girls鈥 critically engagements with influence as part of everyday life, highlighting implications for education and digital practice.

       


       

      Setty, E. & Hunt, J. (2025)

      This policy review critically examines the English government's 2025 statutory guidance on Relationships Education, Relationship and Sex Education and Health Education (RSHE), analysing its educational assumptions, strengths and limitations through the lens of safe uncertainty. While the updated guidance somewhat reinstates key inclusive elements and promotes social and emotional literacy, it continues to position RSHE as a risk domain requiring tight control and cautious delivery. This review highlights areas of concern including contradictions in the guidance's treatment of digital image sharing, the approach to gender and the conditional framing of children's rights and participation. Drawing on the concept of safe uncertainty, we advocate a more coherent rights-based framework, clearer policy direction and sustained investment in teacher support and infrastructure. We call for RSHE policy and practice to move beyond compliance and certainty, and instead build relational, reflective and dialogic spaces where students can engage meaningfully with the ethical and social dimensions of their lives. In doing so, RSHE can fulfil its broader educational promise in preventing harm and supporting the flourishing of students as relational and sexual citizens.


       

      Murphy, J.; Cooke, D.; Griffiths, D.A.; Setty, E.; Winkley, K. (2025)

      Aims: To ask UK women with diabetes whether they have discussed sexual health with healthcare professionals (HCPs) during diabetes care, and to explore communication barriers. Methods: An online questionnaire was developed, based on a published HCP communication survey, piloted by six women with diabetes. A total of 163 participants, recruited via social media and HCP network, completed Part 1 by selecting Likert or narrative response options, providing descriptive data. We report proportions with 95% confidence intervals (Wilson); percentages are calculated using the number responding to each item. Item-level missingness is retained as a non-analysed category, and the n is reported per question. No inferential comparisons were planned a priori. After Part 1 completion, participants could choose to finish, or to continue to Part 2 questions regarding vulval anatomy, function, and vocabulary (77 completed 2A: 80 completed 2B). Part 2 data was analysed thematically. Results: During diabetes care, a minority of participants, 44/163 (27%), said they had ever discussed sexual health, or had been advised how to access sexual health support, 28/163 (17%). If an HCP discussed sexual health, many women said they expected to feel surprised, 114/163 (70%), or pleased, 88/163 (54%). Some participants said they expected HCPs would find the topic inappropriate, 56/163 (36%), or annoying, 44/163 (27%). Some participants expressed HCP gender preference (75/163 [46%] female and 4/163 [3%] male) for such discussion. Part 2 findings revealed unmet sexual health literacy needs with potential to impact on communication with HCPs. Conclusions: Women reported infrequent communication about sexual health and diabetes during diabetes care. Findings highlight potential communication barriers for some participants including the following: unmet educational needs regarding diabetes and sexual health, lack of confidence about available support, fear of a negative HCP response, and preference for the gender of the HCP. Whereas in previous research, HCPs feared upsetting women by discussing sexual health, many participants said they expected to respond positively.


       

      Setty, E (2025)

      This paper explores teenage boys鈥 perspectives on sexual consent through qualitative research conducted in three English schools and a follow-up workshop. Participants described consent as emotionally complex and shaped by peer cultures, reputational anxieties and conflicting gender norms. While some echoed widely circulated narratives, such as fears of false accusations, these were often expressed with ambivalence and used to navigate uncertainty and vulnerability. The study highlights limitations of risk-based, procedural consent education, which boys can experience as accusatory or reductive. Instead, it argues for a relational, dialogic approach that supports emotional literacy, critical reflection and ethical engagement. The paper foregrounds boys鈥 capacity to engage with nuanced accounts of power, intimacy and responsibility when given the space to do so. It concludes that meaningful consent education requires structural support, not just improved messaging, enabling educators to create relational and reflective learning environments amid contested cultural terrains.

       


       

      Setty, E., Hunt, J (2024)

      This article explores the concept of 鈥榮afe uncertainty鈥 as a guiding principle for understanding and supporting adolescent relational intimacies in an era shaped by pervasive digital connectivity and shifting norms. Drawing on research into young people鈥檚 sexual and relational practices and insights from the Reimagining RSE pilot programme, the article argues that dominant educational approaches to consent often present legalistic and over-simplistic binary frameworks of 鈥榶es鈥 and 鈥榥o鈥 that fail to reflect the complexities of adolescent experiences. In contrast, the concept of safe uncertainty offers a more nuanced lens that engages with ambivalence, power dynamics and ethical challenges inherent in contemporary relational contexts. The article situates safe uncertainty within broader discussions of risk, safety and relational wellbeing, illustrating how it can engender critical reflection, emotional literacy and adaptive decision-making among young people. Based on the principles of safe uncertainty, the article advocates pedagogical practices that embrace complexity, encourage open dialogue and move beyond prescription. In doing so, the article argues that promoting safe uncertainty does not entail abandoning safety but rather reimagining it as a dynamic, relational process that supports young people鈥檚 development of meaningful, ethical and pleasurable intimate relationships.

       


       

      Setty, E., Hunt, J (2024)

      At a time when concerns about sexual violence, online harms and the efficacy of Relationships and Sex Education (RSE) frameworks are at the forefront of public discourse, this book offers a timely and necessary intervention. Presenting the concept of 鈥榮afe uncertainty鈥 as a transformative framework for understanding adolescent intimacies and relationships, authors Setty and Hunt critique current deficit models in relationships and sex education in place of a more nuanced engagement with digital intimacies, online sexual learning and sex media, healthy relationships, gender and consent.

      Traditional approaches to RSE, while well-intentioned, can reduce complex social and emotional dynamics to simplistic binaries, leaving young people ill-equipped to navigate the inherent ambivalences and ambiguities of intimacy and relationality. Drawing on original research and case studies from the authors鈥 practice, this text demonstrates how safe uncertainty acknowledges ambiguity and ambivalence as integral parts of relationships and intimacy and involves creating environments where young people can explore their perspectives and experiences without fear of judgment or rigid moral or legal solutions. Aligned with a broader need for relational, developmental and contextual approaches to understanding adolescent intimacies, Setty and Hunt explore how this framework encourages educators, policymakers and researchers to move beyond knowledge-transfer models and instead focus on equipping young people with the skills to navigate uncertainty in ways that promote emotional resilience and ethical decision-making as sexual citizens.

      Connecting the concept of safe uncertainty with critical debates on consent, gender and digital culture, this timely contribution bridges gaps between research, practice and policy on both a national and an international scale.

      Setty E (2025)
      (2025)

      This paper examines how educators, police and children鈥檚 service providers, alongside young people, conceptualise the nature and causes of sexual harm among young people. Drawing on qualitative research conducted in southeast England, we identify four themes: sexual harm as learned behaviour rooted in personal and familial risk factors; normalisation of harmful experiences among girls; neglect and minimisation of boys鈥 victimisation; and evolving digital terrains of harm. While some participants engaged with structural and cultural explanations, many framed sexual harm through an individualised, risk-focused behaviourist lens. We suggest the emphasis on behaviour within the prevailing use of the term 鈥渉armful sexual behaviour鈥 reinforces reductionist perspectives and overlooks interactional, institutional, and socio-cultural dynamics shaping young people鈥檚 experiences. Drawing on sexual script theory and post-digital sexual citizenship, we expand the conceptual terrain, advocating for a holistic and inclusive approach situating sexual harm within broader relational and institutional contexts, requiring nuanced, context-sensitive responses.


       

      Das, R., Boursinou, M. N., Roberts, T., & Setty, E. (2026)

      Communication and journalism studies have historically engaged with local news, often through investigations of local journalism and its audiences. Against this backdrop, in this paper, we pay attention to the role of local news 鈥 defined as news about one鈥檚 locality and neighbourhood, although not solely gathered from local journalism alone 鈥 in the specific situational context of raising children. Locating our work at the intersections of news use scholarship and the sociology of parenting, we draw out four key dimensions of local news use from speaking to 30 parents in England, as part of a three-wave, longitudinal project exploring parental news use. First, we highlight the role of local news as an anchor, often serving as community connections for parents raising their children within specific local and regional contexts. Second, we highlight the role of local news as an escape, where overwhelming geo-political and other crises are sometimes bypassed or deflected, focusing instead on local news, as parents speak of more contained, localised anxieties and opportunities in relation to their children. Third, we highlight the role of local news as a lens, into national and global challenges of difficulty, where people鈥檚 hopes and anxieties about raising children in the wider world are seen through specific, local lenses. Finally, we talk of local news as a site of labour 鈥 where, keeping up with, processing, managing and acting on local news is part of parenting labour in contemporary societies. We conclude by identifying the potentials of these dimensions of situated, contextualised news use research within other relational contexts.

       


       

      Setty, E., Boursinou, M. N., Roberts, T., & Das, R. (2026)

      This paper explores how parents in England navigate news media as a source and site of concern in the context of raising children within a risk society, addressing parental anxiety, misinformation and news literacy concerns. Drawing on a three-wave qualitative longitudinal study with 30 parents, we examine how parents鈥 own struggles with digital news 鈥 marked by misinformation, distrust and emotional saturation 鈥 shape their mediation practices and anxieties about their children鈥檚 engagements. We show how parents negotiate the tensions between protection and autonomy, balancing surveillance with critical digital literacy, and how these dynamics vary across children鈥檚 developmental stages. Our findings reveal a form of recursive anxiety, where parents鈥 concerns about their own media experiences amplify their perceived responsibility to shield and guide their children, particularly in relation to social media and algorithmic influence. By situating these findings within debates on intensive parenting, media literacy and risk society, we highlight how news engagement becomes a key terrain through which parents perform and contest 鈥済ood parenting鈥 in the digital age.

       


       

      Murphy JC, Cooke D, Griffiths D, Setty E, Winkley-Bryant K. (2024)

      Aims

      To explore UK healthcare professionals' practice and attitudes towards asking women with diabetes about sexual health problems, including symptoms of female sexual dysfunction (FSD).

      Methods

      An online questionnaire to address the study aims was developed, piloted by ten healthcare professionals (HCPs) and completed by 111 eligible HCPs, recruited via professional networks and social media. Free text data were analysed and reported thematically. Two questions were analysed to test the hypothesis of differences between men's and women's responses.

      Results

      The majority of respondents did not ask women with diabetes about sexual problems. Multiple barriers to inquiry were reported, including inadequate training, time constraints, competing priorities, the perceived likelihood that questions will cause surprise or distress (especially for certain groups of women), the belief that sexual problems are to be expected as women age, and the belief that FSD is complex or untreatable, with unclear management pathways. Exploratory findings indicated significant differences in men and women's responses (men disagreed more strongly with prioritisation, and fewer reported routine inquiry about sexual problems in their usual practice).

      Conclusions

      HCPs reported not asking women with diabetes about sexual problems during routine care. They described multiple factors reinforcing the silence about sexual health, including inadequate education and perceived social risk for individual HCPs who deviate from the patterns of topics usually discussed in diabetes consultations.